Site Meter Watching Simpsons » Blog Archive » Simpsons vs. Family Guy

Simpsons vs. Family Guy

by Richard Ristow

peterandwife.jpgKeith Olbermann, when asked about his ongoing feud with Bill O’Reilly, once commented that, “If you’re in my position … you punch upwards.” O’Reilly consistently has better ratings, but Olbermann is a man on the move, and he’s turned “Countdown with Keith Olbermann” the best show on MSNBC. His ratings are growing too. This dynamic – the upstart versus the entrenched – could also be applied to an ongoing feud in animation, one that pits fans of The Family Guy against fans of The Simpsons.

The both are satires on contemporary culture, and there is a number of similarities: an overweight and obnoxious dad, a motherhomerandmarge.jpg that’s the brains behind everything, nerdy daughters, a baby that’s much more than what he/she seems, and so much more. Honestly, the difference really is in the writing and the style of delivery. However, it’s important to note that the Simpsons pioneered contemporary prime time animation. As such, it still sits on top of that medium. The Family Guy, as the younger upstart, has to “Punch upwards,” which makes the Simpsons it’s favored target – especially since the two shows share the same network and same programming day, Sunday.

Still, some critics ardently believe that The Family Guy is a better show. Andy Dehnart, writing on MSNBC.com, takes this position:

Still, “The Simpsons” (which debuted in 1989) has directly accused “Family Guy” (which debuted in 1999) of plagiarism in its own episodes. Whatever inspired its creation, “Family Guy” really stands apart because of its flashbacks, cutaways and throwaway references. They have made “Family Guy,” which just aired its 100th episode, the altogether better series.

Dehnart goes on to write:

Throwaway references aside, “Family Guy’s” satire is at once sharper and more obvious than “The Simpsons,” and because of its more aggressive approach, the series is often accused of being unreasonably stupid, pointlessly irreverent or unnecessarily offensive.

That it pushes against boundaries is indisputable. What other show, animated or not, would attempt a musical number with a song titled “You have AIDS,” or feature its main character recounting, in detail, his wife’s failed attempt to get an abortion?

First of all, Dehnart has missed something. There is one animated show that not only would do a musical number about AIDS, but it also featured a talking turd, Satanic animals, and a hate filled fat kid. I’m talking, of course, about South Park.

As for the cutaway scenes, some of them are indeed funny, but other times, they seem extraneous and tacked on, hindering the narrative pace of the episode. The other problem I have is the likeability of the characters. Peter is not Homer, and if one thinks about it, is a much meaner person.


2 Responses to “Simpsons vs. Family Guy”

  1. Tyler Tooley Says:

    Family Guy Is Way Better Than The Simpsons

  2. Watching Simpsons » Blog Archive » New Futurama DVD Says:

    [...] there’s a little bit more to the joke, as this wasn’t really a case of Simpsons tit-for-tat feud with The Family Guy or South Park. Groening created and produced the show, the animation style was almost exactly the [...]

Leave a Reply


About Watching Simpsons

"The thing about my family is there's five of us. Marge, Bart, Girl Bart, the one who doesn't talk, and the fat one. How I loathe him." -Homer

Watching Simpsons is a site that devotes all of its time and energy into bringing Simpsons fans the news, the recaps, the spoilers, and other the cool posts all relating to the weirdly yellow world of Springfield; the Simpsons' hallowed home. Join us everyday for your Simpsons fix. Besides the recaps and spoilers and such, this site comes complete with video, pictures, and the occasional poll for your voting pleasure. Watch for upcoming special features as this site progresses and don't forget to comment. Tell me what you think, tell me what you like and don't like, and definitely tell me what you'd like to see on Watching Simpsons.

Watching Simpsons Author(s)
    » Richard-Ristow

TV Channel Posts

  • Innnteresting!
    So, which one of the houseguests will figure it out first? They're supposed o be fans of the game, right? They never, ever, EVER show pictures on the memory wall without an ulterior motive... No [...]
  • Happy Live Show Day!
    Good Morning, Hamster Lovers! It's our first live show day! I'm so EXCITED! AGP has really stepped it up with this cast, and the two shows so far - I'm extremely pleased so far, and can only hope the [...]
  • Paul Rauch Joining Y&R
    According to TV Guide Paul Rauch is joining The Young & the Restless as a Creative Consultant. In the past Rauch has work on Guiding Light, Santa Barbara, and One Life to Live. [...]
  • Hello Out There????
    It's been a while! This site has been down for a few weeks...451's servers have been having problems, but the upside to that is that they spent a bunch of money on new techie stuff, so things should [...]
  • Rescue Me Mini-Episode, News, Etc.
    And we finally got a sentimental, or at least quasi-sentimental Rescue Me minisode last night. As the firehouse used its final moments to banter about surefire hall of famers and the likelihood they [...]
  • We're Back with 'Heroes' News!
    I have to apologize for my absence as well as the downtime on the site. I'm told that the server issues are fixed and after some brief downtime this week, we should be back for good...and better than [...]
  • The View July 16th
    Today's recap will not be up anytime soon. (I have gotten more realistic. I used to say it would be up later, but really, who am I kidding?). On today's show: Seth Green will be on to promote [...]
  • TV on DVD Review of the Week: Hello Kitty Tells Fairy Tales
    The DVD Hello Kitty Tells Fairy Tales contains episodes from the animated television series called Hello Kitty's Furry Tale Theatre, which originally aired on the Family Channel back in 1986. [...]
  • MTV’s Survivor Style Challenge
    Last week I rambled on about how MTV had not done a challenge since the Gauntlet 3. Well I can stop ranting. MTV is bringing us an all new challenge in the fall. There was a promo the other night [...]
  • Season 1 Flashback: Running to Stand Still
    Good morning, everyone. Ready to catch up on season 1 some more? This time, we’re gonna talk about the episode "Running to Stand Still". When we left The Solis house last time, Carlos’ mom [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Rumer Willis needs a bra, badly!
    While I have nothing against those who feel more comfortable without a bra, I certainly think Rumer Willis case is different. Attending the Power of Paws launch party yesterday, Rumer shows [...]
  • The Birth of Religion - Part 7
    by Seeker SO just what is it that started us on the spiritual path as a race? Graham Hancock started as an investigative journalist and has a string of books behind him that have a common thread [...]
  • Innnteresting!
    So, which one of the houseguests will figure it out first? They're supposed o be fans of the game, right? They never, ever, EVER show pictures on the memory wall without an ulterior motive... No [...]
  • Grass dancing showcases native culture, tradition
    Many students at Central Michigan University take pride in calling themselves "Chippewas." But for Makwa Stevens, a direct descendent of the Chippewa/Ojibwe Indian tribe, the word bears greater [...]
  • Suri at Union Station
      This little number surprised me as I never thought Katie would put her daughter in an outfit she's already worn. BUT I LOVE this Pucci dress. Isn't it cute on her? Oh and for those of you that [...]
  • Sign the Petition Against Madatory Green Lightbulbs
    This post is aimed more for American readers. My apologies to non-American readers. You can go look at Brad Pitt photos here. Anyway, American Migraineurs... A petition to Congress has been [...]
  • Enemas and Enemies
    And, naturally, all hell breaks loose - and not between who you think. We didn't see the actual fight, but it's been nothing but aftermath ever since. April started talking behind Keesha's back and [...]
  • Hello Out There????
    It's been a while! This site has been down for a few weeks...451's servers have been having problems, but the upside to that is that they spent a bunch of money on new techie stuff, so things should [...]
  • If I had a Million Dollars I'd buy a shit-ton of Coke
    Barenaked Ladies singer, Steven J. Page, was arrested in central New York on Friday and was charged with fourth degree criminal possession of a controlled substance, that substance being tasty, tasty [...]
  • Financial support helps reinstate men’s swimming
    Team to compete fully in 2008-09 Arizona State University Vice President for Athletics Lisa Love announced July 15, that the athletic department is fully reinstating the sport of varsity men’s [...]